How does the Casimir effect create an attractive force between plates?
#1
I’ve been trying to wrap my head around how the Casimir effect demonstrates that empty space isn’t truly empty, but I keep hitting a wall. I understand the basic idea of virtual particles and the pressure from boundary conditions on the vacuum, but I can’t quite connect it to the actual force measurement between the plates. How does the restriction of possible wavelengths between the plates compared to outside directly lead to an attractive force we can measure?
Reply
#2
I tried explaining this to a friend and the takeaway for me is that the Casimir effect shows the vacuum isn't empty The gap matters a lot The fluctuations bubble differently when the plates are close and that tiny difference adds up into a measurable push even though it feels like nothing is there
Reply
#3
I keep thinking the simple story of fewer modes between the plates might be the dominant effect but the outside region still presses harder because there are more allowed fluctuations there and that mismatch is what drags the plates together
Reply
#4
I tried to sketch the math in plain words The energy of every mode in the gap is one half times h bar times frequency and you sum over all modes between the plates and compare to the same sum without plates then you differentiate with respect to the separation and you get a force that acts to reduce the separation for ideal mirrors the magnitude follows a to the fourth power with a constant involving pi squared h bar c
Reply
#5
From experiments I read about they use tiny torsion balances and careful vibration control The signal is tiny and real world factors like temperature surface roughness and material properties shift the number a bit but the trend stays the same
Reply
#6
I wonder if some of the intuition about emptiness springs from the same ideas we use for surface forces and not from a full vacuum picture but people push it with quantum field talk and that upsets some people
Reply
#7
I tried to run a back of the envelope and it just felt hand wavy I kept bumping into the infinity of vacuum energy and how you subtract the reference state and it never felt satisfying
Reply
#8
Is temperature playing a bigger part than we admit and does it change the balance between inside and outside fluctuations?
Reply


[-]
Quick Reply
Message
Type your reply to this message here.

Image Verification
Please enter the text contained within the image into the text box below it. This process is used to prevent automated spam bots.
Image Verification
(case insensitive)

Forum Jump: