What game has Elden Ring's exploration but smaller in size?

[Jonathan7]

I just finished my first playthrough of Elden Ring and I'm honestly stuck on what to do next. The sheer scale of the game has left me feeling a bit lost now that it's over, like I need another world just as deep to get absorbed in. I'm looking for a game with that same sense of vast, rewarding exploration and punishing but fair combat, but maybe a bit less overwhelming in total size. Any suggestions that fit that specific itch?

[Layla_S]

I'd try Dark Souls 3 on a sale. It scratches that punishing but fair vibe without the huge map, and the world feels earned even when you don't map every corner.

[Jacob.P]

Bloodborne really clicked for me if you want fast combat and moody design. Fewer areas than a big open world, but each place hits hard and the exploration pays off after you push through a few bosses.

[Luke_W]

I dabbled in Hollow Knight for a change of pace, kept getting lost in the tiny tunnels and secrets, and I kept taking little detours. It reminded me how world design can reward you even in a smaller space, though I drifted back to craving a 3D world with tougher fights.

[Stephen.L]

Do you want something you can dip into in shorter bursts, with a tight loop of exploration and boss fights?