What happens if a return inside a finally block overrides a return from try?
#1
I'm working on some biology education resources and I'm trying to figure out what cell biology concepts are most fundamental for students to grasp. With all the advances in cellular and molecular research, it seems like the basics are more important than ever.

What do you think are the essential cell biology concepts that form the foundation for understanding more complex topics? Also, how do developmental biology insights connect with basic cell biology? I'd love to hear what biology concept explanations have worked well for you when teaching or learning these topics.
Reply
#2
That's a really important question for biology education resources. I think the most fundamental cell biology concepts are membrane structure and function, energy metabolism, and information flow from DNA to protein.

Understanding how cells maintain boundaries, convert energy, and process genetic information provides the foundation for everything else. These concepts come up repeatedly in different contexts throughout biology studies.

What I've found is that students who really grasp these basics have a much easier time understanding more complex topics like cell signaling, differentiation, and disease mechanisms. How do you approach teaching these foundational concepts?
Reply
#3
As a student, I'd add cell cycle regulation and apoptosis to that list. Understanding how cells control their division and programmed death is crucial for grasping everything from development to cancer.

These cell biology concepts keep coming up in different contexts throughout my studies. For example, developmental biology insights often involve precise regulation of cell division and death to shape tissues and organs.

What I've found helpful is learning these concepts through specific examples. Seeing how they play out in real biological systems makes them much more memorable and understandable.
Reply
#4
I think understanding cellular communication and signaling is absolutely essential. How cells send and receive signals governs virtually everything they do, from metabolism to gene expression to movement.

This concept connects beautifully with evolutionary biology too. Comparing signaling pathways across different species provides fascinating insights into how these systems have evolved. Some of the evolutionary biology news about conserved signaling pathways shows how fundamental these mechanisms are.

For biology education resources, I think emphasizing the dynamic nature of cells how they're constantly responding to their environment is really important.
Reply
#5
From a bioinformatics perspective, I think understanding the central dogma DNA to RNA to protein is more important than ever. With all the genetics research updates and molecular biology insights coming out, students need a solid grasp of how genetic information flows through biological systems.

What's changed is that we now understand this isn't a simple linear process. There's regulation at every step, and non coding RNAs play important roles too. Modern biology concept explanations need to capture this complexity while still providing clear foundational understanding.

This is where good biology education resources can make a huge difference helping students navigate from simple models to more nuanced understanding.
Reply
#6
In neuroscience studies, we constantly come back to basic cell biology concepts like membrane potentials and synaptic transmission. Understanding how neurons generate and transmit signals is absolutely fundamental.

What's interesting is how these basic concepts apply differently in different cell types. For example, the same basic principles of membrane transport and signaling apply across cell types, but the specific proteins and mechanisms vary.

I think helping students see these connections how fundamental cell biology concepts manifest in different specialized cell types is really valuable for biology education resources.
Reply
#7
I’m trying to understand the exact behavior of the `finally` block in my exception handling. I had a function that returns a value inside a try block, but I added some cleanup code in finally and now I’m not sure if a return statement inside the finally block will override the earlier return from the try.
Reply
#8
Yep, in my Python project I had a function that did try: return 1 and finally: return 2, and the caller actually got 2 in the end. The block decided the final value.
Reply
#9
After that I stopped returning from the cleanup section and kept cleanup there, and the function returned the try value as expected.
Reply
#10
If the cleanup code raises its own exception, that exception will overshadow the original value.
Reply
#11
I once trusted a return in the cleanup and it surprised me when it ignored the try's value; removing that inner return fixed it.
Reply
#12
Are you sure the issue isn't elsewhere, like a control flow path that never hits the try?
Reply
#13
I drifted into thinking about file handles and how a context manager would feel cleaner; it reminded me of a similar misstep in another project.
Reply
#14
In practice most people avoid returning from the cleanup and instead assign to a variable and return after, or use a context manager.
Reply


[-]
Quick Reply
Message
Type your reply to this message here.

Image Verification
Please enter the text contained within the image into the text box below it. This process is used to prevent automated spam bots.
Image Verification
(case insensitive)

Forum Jump: